EPL Index
·16 January 2025
In partnership with
Yahoo sportsEPL Index
·16 January 2025
David Moyes, the seasoned manager with a storied history at Goodison Park, finds himself in the thick of a relegation dogfight. The irony of his current predicament is stark, given his recent assertion that he did not want to be “at the bottom of the league and fighting relegation.” Fast forward just a fortnight, and that is precisely where he stands as Everton’s saviour-elect.
On New Year’s Eve, Moyes was receiving an OBE for his contributions to football. Yet, by mid-January, he was unveiled as the man tasked with rescuing Everton from the jaws of the Championship. The dismissal of Sean Dyche may have come abruptly, but Moyes’ appointment was hailed by many as a return to stability. As he took charge of his first home game in 4,266 days, the sense of nostalgia was palpable. Moyes himself acknowledged the emotional pull of Everton, writing in the matchday programme that the club “means so much to me and my family.”
Photo IMAGO
However, sentiment alone will not suffice in this unforgiving league. A 1-0 defeat to Aston Villa laid bare the scale of the challenge Moyes faces. “It is a huge challenge at the moment, I can see that,” Moyes admitted post-match. “We are desperately needing to add some quality in areas, mainly to create and to finish – we need to get those levels up.”
One of the most glaring issues Moyes inherits is Everton’s chronic inability to find the back of the net. The Toffees have scored just 15 goals in 20 Premier League games this season, failing to score in nine of their last 11. Former Newcastle striker Alan Shearer did not mince his words when analysing Everton’s plight on Match of the Day: “David Moyes is not a magician but somehow he has got to get goals into this team. Otherwise, they are in massive trouble.”
Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s form epitomises the club’s attacking woes. The striker’s injury-time miss against Villa – a golden opportunity from eight yards – was met with frustration from fans, who are growing weary of such profligacy. Moyes was candid about the situation, stating: “It is not just one game tonight, it is other games, and I think it is there for everybody to see. I can’t magician all that to change, I can’t do it.”
Photo: IMAGO
Adding to the manager’s headaches, Armando Broja, on loan from Chelsea, faces up to 12 weeks on the sidelines with an ankle injury. Moyes hinted that Broja’s return to his parent club may be imminent, further depleting Everton’s attacking options.
The Premier League’s relegation battle is as intense as ever, with Southampton seemingly doomed and the fight for survival boiling down to Everton, Wolves, Leicester, and Ipswich. All four sides are struggling for form, but Everton’s situation feels particularly precarious.
Marc Albrighton, speaking on BBC Radio 5 Live, highlighted the scale of the task awaiting Moyes: “It is a big job for David Moyes at Everton, as previous managers who have been at the helm of this club found out. But I think Moyes was the right appointment at this stage. It is early days in his reign, but I only see them improving and gaining in confidence.”
Confidence, however, will only take the team so far. Everton’s lack of a clinical finisher could be their undoing, and Moyes will be acutely aware of the need to strengthen before the transfer window closes.
With the January transfer window open, Moyes’ ability to bring in reinforcements will be crucial. The club’s compliance with Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) ensures that no financial penalties will hinder their efforts, but Moyes sounded a cautious note about potential incomings. “We will definitely need to do something and find ways to try and act in some way if we can. But in the same breath, if it is not going to improve it, there is no point wasting your money,” he explained.
Everton’s transfer dealings in recent years have been hit-and-miss, and Moyes will be under pressure to identify players who can make an immediate impact. Former boss Sean Dyche previously highlighted the club’s longstanding issues with goalscoring, calling it a problem that predates his tenure by “four or five years.” Moyes will need to work quickly and decisively to address this glaring weakness.
Photo IMAGO
Moyes has built a reputation as a manager capable of steadying the ship, but his task at Everton is arguably one of the most challenging of his career. The goodwill from fans, evident in the rousing reception he received on his return to Goodison, provides a solid foundation. However, that goodwill will not last long if results do not improve.
With two weeks remaining in the transfer window and crucial fixtures on the horizon, Moyes must use all his experience and tactical nous to turn Everton’s fortunes around. The stakes could not be higher; failure to secure Premier League survival would be catastrophic for a club of Everton’s stature.
As Moyes himself put it, “It is a big job, but it is a doable job.” Whether he can deliver remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the fight for survival will define Everton’s season and Moyes’ second spell at the club.