Report: Everton consider summer move for Newcastle midfielder | OneFootball

Everton’s Interest in Sean Longstaff: A Smart Move or a Desperate Gamble?

Everton’s summer recruitment plans are beginning to take shape, and one of the most intriguing potential deals involves Newcastle United’s Sean Longstaff. As reported by TalkSPORT, the Toffees are keen on securing the 27-year-old midfielder, who could be available after struggling for regular game time at St James’ Park this season.

Photo IMAGO

With Everton manager David Moyes reportedly an admirer of Longstaff, this could be an opportunity for the Toffees to add Premier League experience to their squad. However, the key question remains: is this the kind of signing that takes Everton forward, or simply another short-term fix in a never-ending cycle of squad restructuring?

Newcastle’s Perspective on a Potential Sale

Newcastle’s position in this transfer saga is particularly interesting. Selling Longstaff would generate pure profit under the Premier League’s Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR), given that he emerged through their academy.

That financial incentive could play a crucial role in any negotiations, especially as Newcastle look to navigate PSR constraints while continuing their squad evolution under Eddie Howe. Despite Longstaff’s 167 league appearances for the Magpies, his reduced game time this season suggests he may no longer be a key figure in Howe’s long-term plans.

How Would Longstaff Fit at Everton?

Longstaff’s style of play—hard-working, tactically disciplined, and positionally intelligent—would certainly suit Moyes’ system. Everton have lacked consistency in midfield, and adding a player with Longstaff’s experience could provide stability.

Photo IMAGO

However, this potential move raises bigger questions about Everton’s transfer strategy. Are they targeting the right profile of players to push forward, or simply looking for cost-effective, pragmatic deals to fill gaps?

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

For Everton fan’s, this potential transfer feels like a familiar story. Another experienced Premier League player, available at the right price, but is he really the difference-maker the club needs?

There’s no denying that Longstaff is a solid midfielder. He puts in a shift, presses well, and can chip in with the occasional goal. But Everton have spent years signing functional players rather than game-changers. If the ambition is simply to avoid another relegation battle, then sure, Longstaff makes sense. But if the goal is to push towards the top half of the table, is he really the answer?

Another issue is Newcastle’s willingness to sell. If Longstaff was genuinely an important part of their future, would they be so open to letting him go? The financial benefits of the deal for Newcastle are clear under PSR rules, but what’s in it for Everton beyond a short-term squad filler?

This all points to a wider concern—Everton’s recruitment strategy lacks vision. Too often, the club has chased stop-gap signings rather than building a squad with a clear, long-term plan. If Moyes wants to put his stamp on this team, he needs to aim higher than picking up Newcastle’s surplus midfielders.